I liked it. I did most of the stuff. I probably put in a good 30 hours. But I beat it and since then I've had little reason to go back to it.
I just thought that with all the killer games that came out this year like: GTA 4, Gears 2, Metal Gear Solid 4 ... that Fable 2 would not be able to beat those games out.
It'll be interesting to see what other sites like ign and gamespot pick.