Quote by Kat:
Meh I've changed my opinion from bioshock to gta. As much as I hate to make a r* game my GOTY, bioshock just had too many idiosyncrasies to be GOTY IMO. It was a great story with tacked on gameplay and an ending that asked you not to think too hard about the game you just finished. It was beautiful and gripping, but in the end, gta is the game that delivered a story and gameplay that actually worked toward the same goal.
Exactly my thoughts. I also thought about Tomb Raider too, but I think the size and attention to detail gives GTA the lead